CD Reviews

You can search through our extensive database of thousands of releases from Orchestral and Opera to Choral, Jazz and beyond.

 

Written by the expert critics of BBC Music Magazine and with over a hundred new reviews added every month, the archive dates back to the magazine's launch in 1992 and now includes over 20,000 reviews.

NB A few points to bear in mind when searching:

 

 

When looking for symphonies, concertos, etc., the numbers must appear as follows with a space between 'No.' and the number itself:

  • Symphony No. 2
  • Sonata No. 31

 

There is no need to include capital letters or accents in your search – the database is neither case- nor accent-sensitive.

Valery Gergiev conducts Stravinsky

Composer(s):
  • Stravinsky
Works: 
Oedipus Rex; Les noces
Performer: 
Gérard Depardieu (narrator), Sergei Semishkur, Ekaterina Semenchuk, Evgeny Nikitin, Mikhail Petrenko, Alexander Timchenko; Mariinsky Chorus & Orchestra/Valery Gergiev

The near-total triumph of this Oedipus Rex is surprising. Neither of Gergiev’s Barbican performances entirely worked for me, though he built up quite a lather of stylised terror in the final scene. He does so again here, but everything leading up to the dreadful denouement is vividly done, too.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Pushkin Romances

Composer(s):
  • Borodin
  • Cui
  • Dargomyzhsky
  • Glinka
  • Medtner
  • Rachmaninov and Sviridov
  • Rimsky-Korsakov
  • Tchaikovsky
  • Vlasov
Performer: 
Dmitri Hvorostovsky (baritone), Ivari Ilja (piano)

For the Russians, Pushkin is Shakespeare and Byron combined, the founding father of literature in the native language and the originator of its literary forms from folk tale to historical drama, from cynical dandyism to social protest and passionate love lyric.

His poetry’s proverbially musical, but unlike some great verse it both inspires and repays musical settings. Just about every major Russian composer has set some of his work, from operas like Eugene Onegin to the lyrical songs in this recital. 

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Odean Pope: Odeans List

Composer(s):
  • Odean Pope
Works: 
Odeans List
Performer: 
James Carter, Odean Pope, Walter Blanding (sax), Terell Stafford (trumpet), Jeff Watts (drums), George Burton (piano), Lee Smith (bass)

Philadelphian composer and tenor player Odean Pope likes saxophones. So much so he sometimes leads an eight-piece sax choir. But for this outstanding studio date, the former Max Roach sideman has restricted himself to just two of the barnstorming best – Walter Blanding and James Carter – and for balance thrown in a brace of fearsome horn players.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Food: Quiet Inlet

Composer(s):
  • FOOD
Performer: 
Iain Ballamy (drums), Thomas Strønen (sax), Nils Petter Molvaer (trumpet), Christian Fennesz (guitar)

Live sampling, where a performer captures a recorded snapshot of their playing or that of others in real time and stirs the results back into the music, is a much-abused process too often used to paper over gaping cracks in the performers’ musical thinking, as are other forms of electronic augmentation.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Organs, Toccatas & Fantasias

Composer(s):
  • Bach
Titles: 
A musical journey through Bach’s Baroque Europe
Performer: 
Marie-Claire Alain (organ)

Directed by Bruno Monsaingeon, this film follows Marie-Claire Alain around Baroque churches to organs Bach would have known, featuring virtuosic performances and good insights. John Allison

 

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Monteverdi: Il Ritorno d'Ulisse in Patria

Composer(s):
  • Monteverdi
Works: 
Il ritorno d’Ulisse in patria
Performer: 
Kobie van Rensburg, Christine Rice, Cyril Auvity, Joseph Cornwell, Umberto Chiummo, Juan Sancho, Xavier Sabata, Ed Lyon, Hanna Bayodi-Hirt, Robert Burt, Marina Rodriguez-Cusi, Terry Way, Claire Debono, Luigi De Donato, Sonya Yoncheva; Les Arts Florissants/William Christie dir. Pier Luigi Pizzi (Madrid, 2009)

In 1641 Monteverdi made this masterpiece based on Homer’s Odyssey for a public opera house in Venice. It has more characters than you can shake a stick at – presumably one reason why William Christie chose to direct it from the harpsichord – so it needs a cast that has strength in depth.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Clementi: Complete Piano Sonatas

Composer(s):
  • Clementi
Works: 
PIano Sonatas, Vol. 5: Two Sonatas, Op. 34; Six Progressive Sonatinas, Op. 36; Three Sonatas, Op. 37; Sonata in B flat, Op. 46
Performer: 
Howard Shelley (piano)

Howard Shelley continues to restore Clementi’s reputation, overshadowed in his time, and since, by Haydn, with this varied selection from the Six Sonatinas to Op. 34/2 of Beethovenian proportions.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Albéniz & Granados

Composer(s):
  • Albeniz
  • Granados
Works: 
Albéniz: Iberia; Granados: Goyescas
Performer: 
Artur Pizarro (piano)

The pianist that his admirers have long wanted to hear in Iberia delivers a cultivated and probing performance that seems destined to grow greater with familiarity. In this he’s at one with several colleagues.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Kodály: Cello Sonata

Composer(s):
  • Kodaly
Works: 
Solo Cello Sonata, Op. 8; Sonatina; 9 Epigrams; Romance Lyrique; Adagio
Performer: 
Natalie Clein (cello), Julius Drake (piano)

 Zoltán Kodály’s long life (1882-1967) is mirrored in the wide span of works on this excellent new release. More than half a century separates the early Romance lyrique of 1898 and the Nine Epigrams of 1954, a period in which Kodály (along with Bartók) set about collecting folk music from the remotest corners of Hungary.

In his perceptive notes accompanying this release, Calum MacDonald compares Kodály with Vaughan Williams as two great national composers who played a broad role in society.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar

Brahms: Piano Quartet & Clarinet Trio

Composer(s):
  • Brahms
Works: 
Clarinet Trio in A minor, Op. 114; Piano Quartet No. 2 in A, Op. 26
Performer: 
The Nash Ensemble

These are beautifully expressive, thoughtful performances of two unalloyed masterpieces, presented with all the sonic excellence and distinction that we’ve come to expect from Onyx’s series of recordings with the Nash Ensemble. It makes a fine companion to their previous disc of Piano Quartets Nos 1 and 3 which I reviewed some months back.

Performance:
starstarstarstarstar
Sound:
starstarstarstarstar
chevronMore about BBC Worldwide.